April 15, 2014
A fresh look at Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906-1945), both intimate and theological. Marsh (Religious Studies/Univ. of Virginia; The Beloved Community, 2005, etc.) looks anew at the famed theologian and anti-Nazi activist, using rarely glimpsed correspondence to paint a warts-and-all portrait of this German martyr. His dispassionate biography excels in two ways. First, Marsh thoroughly details how Bonhoeffer related to theology and to the theological backdrop of his times. Even as a young man, he rubbed shoulders and corresponded with some of the premier spiritual figures of his day: Niebuhr, Barth and even, to a slight degree, Gandhi. A major point of exploration for the author is how such people shaped the rising theological star. Secondly, Marsh attempts to provide a more closely examined view of Bonhoeffer's personality than past biographers. For instance, he presents Bonhoeffer as spoiled and immature in his early adulthood and as comparably materialistic and peevish in the years leading up to the depths of war. Marsh delves into Bonhoeffer's extraordinarily intimate relationship with his student, Eberhard Bethge, providing more detail, and more fodder for psychoanalysis, than previous biographers. Throughout the work, Marsh looks for ways of revisiting old truths about Bonhoeffer and offering fresh perspectives. Even his death is re-examined. Instead of simply repeating the story told by the concentration camp doctor that he died a quick death with grace and composure, Marsh points out that camp survivors have told different stories about how executions took place, leading one to believe Bonhoeffer suffered a terrible and tortuous end. Such re-examinations of previously unquestioned assumptions are common throughout the book. Though Eric Metaxas' Bonhoeffer (2010) is a more sensitive and well-written account of the subject's life, Marsh also serves readers well. There is no doubt Marsh's portrayal will infuse new controversy into discussions about Bonhoeffer for years to come.
COPYRIGHT(2014) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Starred review from June 15, 2014
In this definitive study, Marsh (religious studies, Univ. of Virginia; God's Long Summer: Stories of Faith and Civil Rights) delivers a fresh portrayal of Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906-45), German pastor, famous theologian, and anti-Nazi activist. He offers an erudite reexamination of Bonhoeffer's life and death as well as a dispassionate exploration of his attitudes and character, using personal correspondence, journals, Bonhoeffer's own publications, and other archival material to illuminate details often omitted from previous biographies and to present multiple points of view on Bonhoeffer from those who knew him. Marsh's portrait is of a spoiled, materialistic, and selfish young man who develops, over time, into a German hero. The writing is clear and concise, the endnotes extensive, and the index generous. VERDICT The intimate glimpses Marsh provides into a great man make for a powerful new account. Fans of the author's previous books will appreciate this, as will historians interested in World War II, and anyone curious about Bonhoeffer. [See Prepub Alert, 10/28/13.]--Michelle Martinez, Sam Houston State Univ. Lib., Huntsville, TX
Copyright 2014 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
Starred review from September 1, 2014
The trajectory of German Lutheran pastor Bonhoeffer's life was set early toward a religious vocation. From his youthful musings on the nature of eternity to his growing confidence in his burgeoning skills as a theologian, listeners move along with Bonhoeffer as he travels the world, gathering spiritual insights at every turn. The road darkened considerably with the rise of the Nazis in his native Germany. With his country and church quickly succumbing to the conflagration of World War II, Bonhoeffer feverishly sought a place for God and the new Christian life in a skeptical, post-religious world. Paul Hecht narrates this comprehensive biography with warmth and perspective. Though the story never descends into intricate apologetics, the theology is deftly handled. Hecht's pronunciation of German names and terms is flawless. VERDICT Recommended for anyone interested in religion, especially in the religious life lived at the edge of mortal danger, and for those curious about the history of Nazi Germany. ["The intimate glimpses Marsh provides into a great man make for a powerful new account," read the starred review of the Knopf hc, "LJ" 6/15/14.]--Denis Frias, Mississauga Lib. Syst., Ont.
Copyright 2014 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.